ITAT Upholds Rs 8 Lakh Commission Disallowance Paid to Wife for Failure to Prove Services Rendered:

The ITAT upheld the disallowance of Rs. 8 lakh commission paid to the assessee's wife, holding that the assessee failed to establish the actual rendering of services despite furnishing a commission agreement.
ITAT Confirms Commission Disallowance Despite Agreement Between Tax Professional and Wife

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has upheld the disallowance of commission expenses amounting to Rs 8 lakh paid by an assessee to his wife, holding that the assessee failed to provide documentary evidence proving that any actual services were rendered in return for the commission.
The present case pertains to the Assessment Year 2020-21. For the year under consideration, Vikas Tyagi, being a tax professional, had declared an aggregate income of Rs 4.84 lakh. During the relevant year, he claimed to have paid a commission of Rs 30.12 lakh to three individuals and HDFC Bank, including Rs 8 lakh to his wife, Smt. Nicky Tyagi.
During the assessment proceedings, the concerned individuals were served notices under Section 133(6) of the Income Tax Act. Smt. Nicky Tyagi claimed that she had provided customer leads and assisted in completing documentation. However, she also claimed that the Rs 8 lakh commission was actually paid directly to another individual, Abhishek Kumar Dubey. The AO questioned why the commission was claimed in her name and why TDS was not deducted in the name of the person who allegedly received the payment.
The assessee submitted that the commission had been claimed in the name of his wife, but she had neither received the amount nor offered it as income in her income tax return. The AO disallowed the entire Rs 8 lakh commission, observing that the assessee had failed to establish that any services were actually provided.
On appeal, the CIT(A) also rejected the claim. It noted that Form 26AS showed that Nicky Tyagi was employed with IFFCO E-Bazar Limited, contradicting the assessee's claim that she was his employee.
Before the ITAT, the assessee relied on a commission agreement dated April 1, 2019, providing for commission at 22.50% on sales routed through his wife. However, the Tribunal had noted that "the assessee had not proved with any documentary evidence to prove the rendition of services either by Smt Nicky Tyagi or by Mr Abhishek Kumar Dubey. Hence the entire claim of expenditure of ₹8,00,000 on account of Commission does not deserve to be allowed as an as a deduction in the hands of the assessee. I find that the learned CITA had rightly confirmed the disallowance made by the learned AO and hence I do not find any infirmity in the said order of the learned CITA. The ground raised by the assessee is hereby dismissed."
The Tribunal also rejected the assessee's alternative request to compute income under Section 44AD, as no supporting details had been furnished before the lower authorities or the Tribunal. Accordingly, the ITAT dismissed the appeal and upheld the disallowance of Rs 8 lakh.
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3083My Recent Articles
- Income Tax Department Issues Supplementary FAQs on FAST-DS 2026: Clarifies Foreign Asset Disclosure Rules
- CBIC Introduces Amendments to Section 16(2) and Insertion of Section 16A of CGST Act to Address ITC Related Difficulties
- CBI Court Sentences Former Sub Post Master to 5 Years Rigorous Imprisonment in Rs 34.62 Lakh Postal Fraud Case
- CBI Apprehends Bank of Baroda Bank Manager and Three DSAs for Demanding 5% Bribe on Rs 1.80 Crore Loan
- CBI Court Sentences Ex-Branch Manager of Union Bank of India to Three Years' Rigorous Imprisonment in Bribery Case
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










