Shuba Lakshmanan | Nov 7, 2021 |
Partially Coated Polyester Fabric (Knitted or Woven) classified at HSN 5903
Introduction: An advanced ruling is a mechanism whereby taxpayers can get answers or clarifications regarding supply of goods and services, directly from tax authorities and the primary objectives for such a mechanism are to reduce litigation, attract FDI due to transparent tax liability, provide certainty with respect to tax liability and disclose ruling in an inexpensive and transparent manner. The Authority for Advanced Ruling (AAR) constituted by the tax authorities interprets tax laws for the taxpayers and it was created to address any issues faced by taxpayers and assist them by providing a decision on the clarification sought. The AAR’s appallet authority is the AAAR (Appellate Authority or National Appellate Authority for Advanced Ruling). Section 95 to Section 106 in Chapter XVII of CGST Act covers the procedures and rules related to advance rulings. An application is made by the taxpayer on the clarification sought by them. The taxpayer is provided an opportunity of being heard by the AAR. If there is consensus on resolution on the clarification sought between the AAR and taxpayer, an ‘Advance Ruling’ is issued by the AAR and on the contrary, the matter is referred to the AAAR.
The question of law which are address through this AAR are as follows:
The applicant, M/S. Supercoat India (Trade name) Ayush Baid (Legal name), requires the intervention of the AAR for correct classification of the cloth material which they process. The applicant processes partially coated Polyester material (woven or knitted) or any other variety of partially coated (having scattered micro-dot print) and currently classifies them under chapter 50-55, 58 or 60. These fabrics are further used as interlining fabric such as in gowns, shirts, coats, etc. The process involved in making the partly coated polyester fabric and other partly coated fabric are elaborated by the applicant. The key point to be noted in the process with reference to the proper classification of the processed fabrics, is listed below.
The applicant is currently classifying the material under Chapter heading 5903 but they are of the opinion that this classification is incorrect as the material processed by the applicant has plastic coating which is fused with other materials as mentioned above. The applicant is of the view that plastic quoted materials having design in them cannot be classified under Chapter heading 5903 and will fall under Chapter 50-55, 58 or 60. It opined that since the processed fabric are polyester materials, they will not fall under Chapter headings 50-53 and can be classified under Chapter 54. The applicant further stated that classification under Chapter 59 is not possible as under a Madras High Court case which was further appealed to CESTAT vide appeal no. E/31/2012, the order stated that cotton fusible interlining fabric should be classified under chapter heading 5903 under omission of chapter note 2(c ) to chapter 59 which reads as follows ‘Textile fabrics, partially or discretely coated with plastic by dot printing process.”
Further the applicant submitted similar advanced rulings passed by other AAR authorities, the significant one to be note being the one passed by the AAR, Uttarakhand in the case of M/S. Goodswear fashion Pvt. Ltd. where the AAR passed order that based on lab reports, the polyester viscose fusing interlining woven fabric should be covered under chapter 55 to 58 and not chapter 59. Further in the case of Ashima Dyecots (P) Ltd., the applicant stated that the case is irrelevant as the fabric in question in the aforementioned case was cotton and not polyester as the present case.
For the above mentioned reasons, the applicant submitted that their product will not fall under chapter heading 5903 or 59 and will be classified under Chapter heading 5407 as their material is woven or knitted polyester fabric. Further they submitted a letter from Man Made Textile Research Association, dated 31.Jul.2021 which provided the following insights about the applicant’s processed fabric.
The revenue is of the contention that the original classification made by the applicant for the processed polyester fusible interlining fabric under Chapter heading 5903 is correct as the materials are textile fabrics, laminated or covered with plastic, impregnated and coated.
The personal hearing by the AAR was on 17. Jun. 2021 and Avinash Poddar appeared on behalf of the applicant and reiterated the facts as stated above. The personal hearing was adjourned few times and the final personal hearing through video-conferencing was held on 31-Jul-2021 and the representative of the applicant made representations similar to what the Man Made Textile Research Association, had made dated 31.Jul.2021.
The AAR acknowledged the facts mentioned by Man Made Textile Research Association, and reiterated the question in hand, i.e., of the processed fabric must be classified under Chapter heading 5903 or Chapter heading 50-55, 58 or 60. The AAR stated that classification of goods under GST is basis the HSN and the custom tariff is basis the HSN. The AAR further explained that the Chapter notes are part and parcel of the Customs Tariff Act, 1975 and the explanatory notes to the HSN have used for interpreting the correct classification. The general principle followed for classifying under HSN is to go by the Section headings or Chapter Notes and this approach has been adopted by AAR to arrive at the conclusion.
The AAR had reproduced Chapter 59 and Heading 5903 as is. The AAR sighted the difference between Chapter 59 and Heading 5903 where Heading 5903 specifically quotes “laminated with plastics (eg: poly(vinyl chloride)) and also took into account the Man Made Textile Research Association’s observations.
The AAR, based on explanatory notes to Heading 5903 confirmed its findings on the following points to be fulfilling the explanatory notes to Heading 5903.
AAR concluded that since the fabric fits the above explanatory notes to Heading 5903, the fabric has to fall under HSN 5903.
Further the AAR confirmed that without taking into consideration the omission of chapter note 2(c) to chapter 59 which was issued as a circular dated 27.Nov.1998, the AAR could conclude as above. Further with respect to the other advanced rulings cited by the applicant, the AAR is of the contention that as per Section 103 of CGST Act, the advanced rulings are specifically binding on the applicant and hence are not considered for making the final order.
The AAR therefore ruled that the subject mentioned fusible interlining fabric made from polyester has to be classified under HSN 5903.
In case of any Doubt regarding Membership you can mail us at [email protected]
Join Studycafe's WhatsApp Group or Telegram Channel for Latest Updates on Government Job, Sarkari Naukri, Private Jobs, Income Tax, GST, Companies Act, Judgements and CA, CS, ICWA, and MUCH MORE!"
