ITAT Deletes Rs 1.5 Crore Addition, Says Alleged Accommodation Entry Cannot Automatically Be Treated as Taxpayer's Income:

The ITAT held that WhatsApp chats and statements recorded during a search failed to establish taxpayer' involvement in the alleged cash transaction.
ITAT Holds WhatsApp Chats Insufficient Evidence

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Ahmedabad Bench, has upheld the deletion of a Rs 1.5 crore addition made under Section 69C of the Income Tax Act in the case of Khushi Advertising Ideas. The Tribunal held that the department had failed to establish that the company was involved in the alleged cash transaction linked to an accommodation-entry arrangement.
The dispute arose on February 21, 2023, when the tax authorities conducted a search of the Miraj Group. During the operation, the investigators recovered WhatsApp chats between Amit Sharma, a director of Miraj Entertainment Limited (MEL) and Sanjay Singh. The chats were found on the mobile phone of Amit Sharma. According to the conversation, Sharma had requested Singh to arrange Rs 2 crore in cash.
From the amount of Rs 2 crore, Rs 1.5 crore was allegedly transferred to Khushi Advertising Ideas in Ahmedabad. As an identifying token for the transaction, a Rs 10 note photograph was allegedly sent to Singh. According to a statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Income Tax Act, Singh had transferred Rs 1.5 crore to Ajay in exchange for the token.
During the assessment, the assessing officer alleged that Khushi Advertising Ideas had received cash from MEL and routed the amount back through banking channels by recording bogus expenses. The allegation was based on WhatsApp messages recovered from Sharma’s phone and a statement recorded under Section 132(4) of the Income Tax Act. In his statement, Singh claimed that he had delivered Rs 1.5 crore to a person named Ajay in exchange for a token. The officer interpreted the message containing the words “1.5 ahmedabad khushi” as a reference to the advertising company and treated the amount as unexplained expenditure. Consequently, the company’s assessed income increased from Rs 14.56 crore to approximately Rs 16.06 crore.
Challenging the addition, the company argued that it was not part of the WhatsApp conversation and that the department had not established any connection between Ajay and the company. It also maintained that its business transactions with MEL were genuine and that the supporting documents had been submitted during assessment proceedings.
The ITAT observed that the WhatsApp messages and statements did not establish that the company had received the alleged cash. It noted that the reference to “1.5 ahmedabad khushi” could require further investigation but was not sufficient to prove the company's involvement. The department had also failed to establish Ajay’s connection with the company.
The Tribunal further clarified that the amount involved in an alleged accommodation-entry arrangement cannot automatically be treated as the taxpayer’s income. Accordingly, it upheld the deletion of the Rs 1.5 crore addition under Section 69C and dismissed the department’s appeal.
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3056My Recent Articles
- Mahadev Betting App Case: CBI Conducts Searches at 33 Locations Across 6 States, Dismantles Live Panels
- Kerala Businessman Loses Rs 1.45 Crore in Investment Scam Using AI-Generated Video Featuring Finance Minister
- ITAT Deletes Rs 1.70 Crore Additions, Says Purchases Cannot Be Disallowed Without Rejecting Book
- RBI Imposes Rs 9 Lakh Penalty on MobiKwik for Violating PPI and Fraud Reporting Norms
- ITAT Quashes Assessment Order as ACIT Lacked Jurisdiction Without Transfer Order under Section 127
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










