ITAT Deletes Rs 30.48 Lakh Addition, Holds Sales Already Recorded in Books Cannot Be Added Again as Income from Other Sources:

ITAT Deletes Rs 30.48 Lakh Addition, Holds Sales Already Recorded in Books Cannot Be Added Again as Income from Other Sources

The ITAT held that sales receipts already recorded in the books and offered to tax could not be added again merely on the basis of a third-party statement without providing an opportunity for cross-examination.

ITAT Says AO Ignored Documentary Evidence of Genuine Sales

authorSaloni KumaridateNov 21, 2026
Last update on Nov 21, 2026

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has deleted an addition made to the taxpayer under the head ‘Income from Other Sources’, holding that the amount represented sales receipts already disclosed in the assessee’s books of account.

The assessee, Pakman International, had filed its income tax return (ITR) for the Assessment Year 2014-15, declaring an aggregate income amounting to Rs 7.67 lakh. Subsequently, the assessee's case was reopened by the Assessing Officer (AO) under Section 147 of the Income Tax Act, and a notice under Section 148 of the Act was served.

UAE Deports Mohd Mazin to India After INTERPOL Red Notice Over Alleged Exploitation of 14 Women

The assessee was asked to file an ITR within the time limit prescribed in the Section 148 notice; however, the assessee did not. Thereafter, the assessee was served another notice under Section 142(1) of the Act, reminding it to file an ITR in response to the Section 148 notice. On December 10, 2021, the assessee made a submission that it had already furnished its tax return for the concerned assessment year and also asked the authority to disclose the reason behind reopening its assessment.

However, on checking, the e-filing portal did not include any tax return furnished by the assessee. Consequently, the AO did not find it relevant to specify the assessee's reasons behind reopening its assessment.

ITAT Upholds Rs 8 Lakh Commission Disallowance Paid to Wife for Failure to Prove Services Rendered

Later, it was noted by the AO that the assessee had indeed filed an ITR; however, it was much after the time prescribed in the notice under section 148. Hence, the return in this case cannot be considered valid. The AO completed the reassessment under Section 144, making an addition of Rs 30.48 lakh to the assessee's income, alleging that the assessee had received accommodation entries through sales made to Shri Atul Tyagi of Disha Enterprises. The AO relied on Shri Tyagi's statement recorded during a search, wherein he admitted to providing accommodation entries to various concerns.

Aggrieved, the assessee approached the ITAT, contending that the amount represented genuine trading receipts from sales already recorded in its profit and loss account and included in its total turnover.

Income Tax Department Issues Supplementary FAQs on FAST-DS 2026: Clarifies Foreign Asset Disclosure Rules

After examining the records, the Tribunal noted that "the learned AO having ignored the income tax return filed by the assessee had actually taken due cognizance of the same in the final computation of income as he starts the determination of total income from the income returned by the assessee in the sum of Rs 7,67,498. The assessee on his part had duly furnished all the details to prove the veracity of the sales made to Disha Enterprises (Shri Atul Tyagi) before the learned AO. None of these documents were found to be either deficient or false by the lower authorities. The entire addition has been made merely by placing reliance on the statement of Shri Atul Tyagi by completely ignoring the documentary evidences placed on record. Even the cross examination of Shri Atul Tyagi was not provided to the assessee."

Accordingly, the ITAT held that the addition was unjustified, as the sales receipts had already been offered to tax. The Tribunal deleted the entire addition of Rs 30.48 lakh and allowed the assessee's appeal.

About Author

LinkedIn

Saloni Kumari

Content Writer

Saloni is a Content Writer with 2+ years of experience at studycafe.in. She writes legal, taxation, and finance related content including GST, Income Tax etc. Skilled in translating complex judicial pronouncements and regulatory developments into clear, and reader-friendly articles. Experienced in covering judgements of ITAT, High Court, GSTAT, and news related to Income Tax, GST, and corporate law. She can be reached at [email protected].
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3088
Up Next

Loading suggestions…