ITAT Holds Reopening Based on Incorrect Search Statements Invalid:

ITAT Holds Reopening Based on Incorrect Search Statements Invalid

The ITAT Delhi rules that mere search statements without supporting evidence cannot justify reopening under Sections 147 and 148.

ITAT Quashes Reassessment Proceedings

authorSaimadateNov 16, 2026
Last update on Nov 16, 2026

The appeals were filed by M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited and M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited against separate orders dated January 13, 2026, passed by the CIT (A), for Assessment Year 2013-14. In the case of M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited, the AO reopened the assessment alleging that the company had acquired 50% shareholding in M/s PSS Agro & Investments Private Limited by utilising accommodation entries received from various entities. 

MCA Reminds Companies of November 29 Deadline to File PAS-6 for September 2026 Half-Year

Similarly, in the case of M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited, the department alleged that the company had received a loan of Rs. 1.75 crore from M/s Obedient Tradelink Private Limited, which was allegedly engaged in providing accommodation entries. The AO relied upon search statements of Shri Praveen Agarwal and Shri Manpreet Piplani to support the allegations concerning the respective entities. Consequently, the department treated the alleged credits as unexplained and also proposed additions towards the commission component allegedly embedded in the transactions.

The Tribunal examined the reasons recorded for reopening in both cases and found that the Os had primarily relied upon statements of the alleged entry operators to establish that the concerned entities were accommodation entry providers.

Rane Holdings Subsidiary Gets Relief as GST Authorities Withdraw Rs 11.88 Crore Demand

In the case of M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited, the statement of Shri Manpreet Piplani did not establish that M/s Obedient Tradelink Private Limited was an accommodation entry provider. The Tribunal further noted that the department had not questioned M/s Obedient Tradelink Private Limited as an accommodation entry provider in the case of M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited, despite its involvement as the other 50% investor in M/s PSS Agro & Investments Private Limited.

The Tribunal also referred to the CBDT Circular dated March 10, 2003, observing that mere recording of search statements, in the absence of supporting evidence, does not carry evidentiary significance under the provisions of the Income Tax Act. Thus, the Tribunal found that the very foundation of reopening in both cases suffered from incorrect factual assumptions.

B.Tech Biotechnology in Delhi NCR: Exploring The Curriculum, College Facilities and Career Prospects

In view of the above findings, the Tribunal held that the reassessment proceedings initiated against both companies were unsustainable. Accordingly, the Tribunal quashed the reopening proceedings initiated in the cases of M/s KKH Infrastructure Private Limited and M/s My Choice Agencies Private Limited.

About Author

LinkedIn

Saima

Content Writer

Saima is a Law graduate with a passion for research and content writing. She writes for Finance, Taxation and Legal Updates at Studycafe.in, simplifying complex legal decisions by the ITAT, High Court, AAR and GSTAT into uncomplicated and clear explanations.
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
651
Up Next

Loading suggestions…