Loose Papers Alone Insufficient for Section 69A/69B Additions

The assessee was an individual and also a partner in many real estate companies. Initially, he had filed his returns for an income of Rs. 14.87 lakh. The survey was carried out among groups under Section 133A, and documents were confiscated. On the basis of the search conducted, the AO reopened the assessment under Section 147 and reassessed the assessee by making considerable additions.

As per the AO, the assessee had purchased a flat in which he had paid an amount of Rs. 10.39 lakh and treated this as unexplained income under Section 69A. Additional assessments were made against him to the tune of Rs. 1.68 crore and Rs. 49.59 lakh, respectively, under Sections 69A and 69B on the basis of incriminating documents discovered during the survey.

However, the CIT(A) deleted all additions, as the material produced did not link the assessee to them.

Central Issue: Whether additions under Sections 69A and 69B can be sustained solely on the basis of loose papers found during the survey without establishing a clear nexus with the assessee?

Tribunal’s Ruling: The Tribunal, while dismissing the appeal, held that the whole case against the assessee raised by the AO is an assumption based on some papers without any evidence to show its relation to the documents of the assessee. Going through the seized papers, it was noted by the Tribunal that the figures quoted by the AO do not tally with those in the seized papers. All that was mentioned is the rate per sq ft, and even this does not relate to the alleged property, which had been purchased by the assessee.

The Tribunal further held that the facts presumed by the AO are inaccurate. It also pointed out that although Section 292C provides for a presumption based on certain documents, it is not absolute and can only be claimed where there exists a direct relation between the documents and the assessee. No such relation exists in the instant case. Thus, it was concluded by the Tribunal that the additions were merely conjectures, and therefore, the additions were deleted.

To Read Full Order, Download PDF Given Below.