Husband Not Liable for Wife’s SBI Credit Card Spending on Her Garment Business, ITAT Deletes Rs 15.67 Lakh Addition:

The ITAT deleted the addition made on account of SBI credit card expenses after accepting that the payments were made by the assessee’s wife and were not claimed as business expenditure by the assessee.
ITAT Grants Relief of Rs 15.67 Lakh to Husband

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Delhi Bench, has deleted an addition of Rs 15.67 lakh made by the Assessing Officer (AO) on account of SBI credit card expenses, holding that the expenses were incurred by the assessee’s wife from her disclosed sources of income and did not relate to the assessee.
Vijay Sharma (assessee) had declared an aggregate income amounting to Rs 10.51 lakh for the Assessment Year 2018-19. The Assessing Officer (AO) selected the case for scrutiny after noting that the assessee had made large payments during the year under consideration for making credit card purchases.
When the case was thoroughly verified, it was observed that the assessee had made transactions amounting to Rs 22.85 lakh using credit cards (Rs 1.12 lakh in HDFC Bank credit card, Rs 15.67 lakh in SBI credit card and Rs 6.04 lakh in Standard Chartered Bank credit card).
During the proceedings, the assessee told the AO that the money spent on the SBI credit card pertained to his wife, named Mrs Jyoti Sharma, who owns her separate business. To prove the same, he also submitted confirmation before the tribunal from her wife. When the claim was verified, it was noted that the amount of Rs 15.67 lakh spent on the SBI credit card was personal in nature and not related to the assessee's business.
It was further observed that the assessee's wife is a women entrepreneur, and while she was making freelance transactions of garments, she had used the assessee’s credit card. Thereafter, Jyoti was served a notice under section 133(6). In response to the notice, she filed income tax returns (ITRs) for assessment years 2016-17, 2017-18 and 2018-19.
Following the filing of the tax returns by Jyoti, the AO noted that she had used Form No. 1 for filing her tax returns and not Form No. 3 or 4, which confirms that she was not engaged in any business. This makes all the claims made by her false. Accordingly, the AO treated the amount as unexplained and made an addition of Rs 15.67 lakh, which was subsequently upheld by the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)].
The assessee claimed that "the SBI credit card and Standard Chartered Bank credit card were used by his wife Mrs Jyoti Sharma for her business purposes and that the amount of ₹15,67,409 spent in SBI credit card pertains to the transactions carried out by his wife and the same does not pertain to the assessee at all."
The assessee also furnished sources of all the transactions of Rs 15.67 lakh made by her wife Mrs Jyoti Sharma:
"a) Payments made by cheque by Mrs Jyoti Sharma out of her income and savings –₹6,00,797
b) Payments made by Mrs Jyoti Sharma out of available cash balance as on 31/3/2017 - ₹1,62,850
c) Payments made by Mrs Jyoti Sharma out of cash sales of ₹9,27,200 on sale of garments and other items – ₹8,03,762
Total payments - ₹15,67,409"
The key issue raised before the ITAT, Delhi, was whether the first appellate authority, i.e., the CIT(A) was fair in making an addition of Rs 15.67 lakh on account of SBI credit card expenses during the relevant year.
The ITAT observed that the assessee had furnished his wife's confirmation, income tax return acknowledgements and complete details explaining the sources of payments. The Tribunal also noted that the assessee had not claimed the SBI credit card expenses as business expenditure in his own income tax return.
Accordingly, the Tribunal held that no disallowance could be made when the assessee had not claimed the expenditure in the first place. It deleted the entire addition of Rs 15.67 lakh and allowed the assessee's appeal.
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3090My Recent Articles
- ITAT Deletes Rs 30.48 Lakh Addition, Holds Sales Already Recorded in Books Cannot Be Added Again as Income from Other Sources
- Credit Card Fraud Without OTP or PIN: Six Essential Precautions to Protect Yourself
- Bengaluru Software Engineer Loses Rs 5.46 Lakh in Credit Card Fraud Despite Not Sharing OTP or PIN
- GST Department Adds Metro Rail as New Mode of Transportation in E-Way Bill System, Effective November 1
- UAE Deports Mohd Mazin to India After INTERPOL Red Notice Over Alleged Exploitation of 14 Women
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










