ITAT Deletes Foreign Investment Addition and Sundry Creditors Addition:

ITAT Deletes Foreign Investment Addition and Sundry Creditors Addition

The ITAT Delhi holds source of source requirement cannot be applied retrospectively.

ITAT Remands Share Application Money Addition

authorSaimadateNov 22, 2026
Last update on Nov 21, 2026

Sahara Tutner Constructions Ltd. was engaged in providing management services in relation to various construction sectors. For AY 2013-14, the assessee filed its original return declaring a loss of Rs. 15,69,82,968, which was subsequently revised to Rs. 15,68,98,089. The case was selected for scrutiny under CASS for reasons including a high TDS refund ratio, substantial expenses claimed in the Profit and Loss Account, unsecured loans from persons who had not filed income tax returns and a high depreciation claim.

During assessment proceedings, the AO made several additions and disallowances, including Rs. 6,52,55,696 towards share application money under Section 68 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, Rs. 1,28,85,956 towards sundry creditors, Rs. 4,89,20,490 on account of differences between Form 26AS and the Profit and Loss Account, and Rs. 2,55,95,986 towards ad hoc disallowance of expenses at 10%. On appeal, the CIT(A) granted partial relief.

CBIC Introduces Amendments to Section 16(2) and Insertion of Section 16A of CGST Act to Address ITC Related Difficulties

The Tribunal observed that an amount of Rs. 1,31,47,650 received during FY 2011-12 was sourced from the maturity proceeds of five fixed deposits credited to Anant Jain's SBI account. It also noted that the assessment for AY 2012-13 had already been completed under Section 143(3), without raising any doubt regarding the share capital received from him.

Further, the Tribunal noticed a credit entry of Rs. 10 crore in Anant Jain's Citi Bank account, out of which Rs. 1.35 crore was transferred to the assessee. The investor had also furnished confirmation dated 20.10.2017 acknowledging the investment.

ITAT Holds Receipts from Indian Customers Not Taxable as Royalty or FTS Under India-US DTAA

Considering these facts, the Tribunal set aside the orders of the lower authorities and restored the issue to the AO for verification of Anant Jain's bank accounts by obtaining the relevant records directly from the bank.

The Tribunal observed that the assessee had furnished the names of the parties, the nature of services received and the amounts outstanding. It also noted that the corresponding expenses relating to these creditors had simultaneously been disallowed by the AO.

CBI Court Sentences Former Sub Post Master to 5 Years Rigorous Imprisonment in Rs 34.62 Lakh Postal Fraud Case

The Tribunal pointed out that the same parties appeared in the list of outstanding creditors as well as in the expenses claimed towards services rendered. Thus, making an addition towards outstanding creditors while also disallowing the corresponding expenditure resulted in double addition. Accordingly, the Tribunal directed the AO to delete the entire addition of Rs. 1,28,85,956 made towards sundry creditors.

About Author

LinkedIn

Saima

Content Writer

Saima is a Law graduate with a passion for research and content writing. She writes for Finance, Taxation and Legal Updates at Studycafe.in, simplifying complex legal decisions by the ITAT, High Court, AAR and GSTAT into uncomplicated and clear explanations.
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
676
Up Next

Loading suggestions…