ITAT Dismisses Section 154 Appeal, Says Rectification Cannot Substitute Appeal Against Original Assessment Order:

The ITAT dismissed the appeal against rejection of a Section 154 rectification application, holding that rectification proceedings cannot be used as a substitute for an appeal against the original assessment order.
ITAT Dismisses Appeal After Finding Section 154 Application Was Used to Cover Non-Filing of Original Appeal

The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Chennai Bench, dismissed an appeal challenging the rejection of a rectification application furnished under Section 154 of the Income Tax Act, holding that such an application cannot be used as a substitute for an appeal against the original assessment order.
The present matter belongs to Velusamy Meenal, who filed his income tax return (ITR) for Assessment Year 2017-18, disclosing a total income of Rs 1.03 crore. The Assessing Officer (AO) selected the case for scrutiny in order to examine large cash deposits and differences in the opening and closing Written Down Value (WDV). The AO completed the assessment after rejecting the books of account under Section 145(3) of the Act and estimated the assessee's aggregate income at 3.5% of total contract receipts of Rs 60.77 crore, resulting in an assessed income of Rs 2.12 crore.
The aggrieved assessee filed an appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) [CIT(A)] and, alongside, also filed a rectification application under Section 154. However, the same application was rejected by the AO, and the appeal before the CIT(A) was also dismissed. This further led the assessee to approach the ITAT. The appeal before the tribunal was filed with a delay of 853 days. Consequently, the assessee submitted an affidavit explaining the delay and provided an acknowledgement number for the belated appeal filed against the original assessment. Considering the authenticity of the reasons served by the assessee, the tribunal condoned the delay and accepted the appeal.
During the hearing, the assessee's authorised representative confirmed that an appeal against the original assessment order dated December 27, 2019, was also pending before the CIT(A). During the personal hearing, the Tribunal observed that "the application filed by the assessee u/s. 154 of the Act was nothing but an attempt to cover the vacuum created by non-filing of appeal against the original assessment order and the present appeal can’t be the substitute for appeal to be filed against the original assessment order, legally also."
Accordingly, the ITAT dismissed the appeal without examining the merits of the issues raised.
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3062My Recent Articles
- CBI Arrests Two NCB Sub-Inspectors Over Accepting Rs 12 Lakh Bribe to Avoid False Implication in NDPS Case
- ITAT Says PCIT Approval Insufficient to Issue Section 148 Notice After Expiry of 3-Year Time Limit
- Man Earning Rs 15,000 Monthly Shocked as Rs 350 Crore Transactions Made in His Name Using Fake Documents
- Cyber Criminals Defraud 72-Year-Old Retired Bank Employee of Rs 1.42 Crore Through Digital Arrest Scam
- ITAT Deletes Rs 1.5 Crore Addition, Says Alleged Accommodation Entry Cannot Automatically Be Treated as Taxpayer's Income
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










