ITAT Deletes Rs 3.90 Crore Additions on Stock Mismatch, Cash Deposits and Proposed Loan:

The ITAT Delhi holds that genuine business sales cannot be taxed again as unexplained income without rejecting books of account.
ITAT Dismissed Revenue’s Appeal

The assessee is an individual engaged in business through his proprietorship concern, M/s Jai Guru Dev Packers which filed his return of income for AY 2017-18 declaring total income of Rs 35,94,630. A survey under Section 133A of the Income Tax Act was conducted at the assessee's business premises on 7 September 2016. During the survey, the assessee surrendered Rs 4 crore, which he subsequently retracted through a letter dated 13 October 2016.
During the assessment proceedings, the AO made several additions. The CIT(A) deleted all the additions after examining the explanations and supporting documents furnished by the assessee.
The Tribunal observed that the stock mismatch arose because the assessee's accounts department could not electronically update routine accounting entries on the date of the survey due to a temporary shortage of staff.
The Tribunal held that once the corresponding cash sales had already been recorded and subjected to tax, making another addition for the same amount under the head stock mismatch would result in double taxation, which is impermissible in law. Importantly, the Tribunal noted that the assessee maintained audited books of account, which were produced before the AO but were never rejected under Section 145 of the Act. Accordingly, the addition of Rs 2,88,51,600 was held to be unsustainable.
Regarding the addition of Rs 33.50 lakh under Section 69A, the Tribunal observed that the AO had primarily relied upon temporary negative cash balances reflected in the books during the survey. Since no tangible evidence of bogus transactions was brought on record, the Tribunal upheld the CIT(A)'s decision deleting the addition of Rs 33.50 lakh.
In the present case, the Revenue failed to establish that any actual money or monetary value had entered the possession or ownership of the assessee. Accordingly, the Tribunal held that a hypothetical or non-existent inflow of funds cannot be brought to tax under Section 69A. The addition of Rs 60 lakh was therefore deleted.
The Tribunal found no infirmity in the order passed by the CIT(A) deleting all four additions aggregating to Rs 3,89,26,600. The Tribunal accordingly dismissed all the grounds raised by the Revenue and dismissed the Revenue's appeal in its entirety.
About Author
Saima
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
677My Recent Articles
- ITAT Holds Rs. 43 Lakh Loan Credit Pertained to Earlier Assessment Year
- ITAT Deletes Foreign Investment Addition and Sundry Creditors Addition
- ITAT Remands Appeals for Fresh Adjudication Over Alleged Double Disallowance Under Section 40(a)(ia)
- ITAT Quashes Section 153C Assessments Due to Invalid Satisfaction Note
- ITAT Allows Deduction on Interest Earned by Cooperative Society from Surplus Investments
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










