GST Orders Quashed! HC Slams Officer for Dismissing Reply as "Not Brief" Without Reason:

Madras High Court quashes GST orders for violating natural justice, slams tax officer for rejecting replies without reasoning.
HC Quashes GST Orders for Violating Natural Justice

GST Orders Quashed! HC Slams Officer for Dismissing Reply as "Not Brief" Without Reason
The Court found that the tax department had acted unfairly and carelessly by not looking at the replies or the reasons of the petitioner. Hence, the Court quashed all the tax and penalty orders and remanded the matter to the department for fresh consideration. HC directs the tax department to, at this time, properly consider the replies of the petitioner before issuing the final order.
The current case revolves around three Writ Petitions (W.P. Nos. 28076, 28079, and 28080 of 2025) filed by an individual named Tvl. K.K. Hariharan in the Madras High Court. In all three writ petitions, the respondent is the same, i.e., the State Tax Officer, Roving Squad 3, from the Office of the Commercial Tax Officer, Coimbatore.
Hariharan filed these three writ petitions under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Through the writ petition, Hariharan challenged certain Goods and Services Tax (GST) assessment orders, related to the assessment years 2020-21, 2022-23, and 2023-24, issued by the tax officer. These orders included:
- Three assessment orders dated 21.01.2025 and 03.02.2025
- The DRC-07 demand notices issued under Section 73 of the CGST Act
- The rectification orders dated 18.07.2025
- The DRC-08 penalty orders dated 18.07.2025
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
Saloni is a Content Writer with 2+ years of experience at studycafe.in. She writes legal, taxation, and finance related content including GST, Income Tax etc. Skilled in translating complex judicial pronouncements and regulatory developments into clear, and reader-friendly articles. Experienced in covering judgements of ITAT, High Court, GSTAT, and news related to Income Tax, GST, and corporate law. She can be reached at [email protected].
Saloni is a Content Writer with 2+ years of experience at studycafe.in. She writes legal, taxation, and finance related content including GST, Income Tax etc. Skilled in translating complex judicial pronouncements and regulatory developments into clear, and reader-friendly articles. Experienced in covering judgements of ITAT, High Court, GSTAT, and news related to Income Tax, GST, and corporate law. She can be reached at [email protected].
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3085My Recent Articles
- UAE Deports Mohd Mazin to India After INTERPOL Red Notice Over Alleged Exploitation of 14 Women
- ITAT Upholds Rs 8 Lakh Commission Disallowance Paid to Wife for Failure to Prove Services Rendered
- Income Tax Department Issues Supplementary FAQs on FAST-DS 2026: Clarifies Foreign Asset Disclosure Rules
- CBIC Introduces Amendments to Section 16(2) and Insertion of Section 16A of CGST Act to Address ITC Related Difficulties
- CBI Court Sentences Former Sub Post Master to 5 Years Rigorous Imprisonment in Rs 34.62 Lakh Postal Fraud Case
Up Next
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts









