SEBI Proposes Re-introduction of Open Market Buybacks Under Revised Tax Framework

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has issued a consultation paper inviting stakeholders' feedback on its proposal to reintroduce buybacks of shares in the open market.
<h3 id="reason-for-discontinuation-of-the-open-market-buyback">Reason for Discontinuation of the Open Market Buyback</h3>
From April 1, 2025, the practice of companies buying back shares from the open market was discontinued. This decision was taken due to concerns about fairness among shareholders and issues related to the tax structure at that time.

<div class="related-article-inline">Also Read<a href="/sebi-allows-cost-accountants-to-conduct-annual-audits-of-investment-advisers-414695.html" class="related-link">SEBI Allows Cost Accountants to Conduct Annual Audits of Investment Advisers</a></div>

Sebi further added that in open market buybacks, it was possible for a company’s entire buyback order to be matched with the sell orders of just one or a few shareholders. As a result, other shareholders who wished to participate might not get the opportunity to sell their shares.

Additionally, there were concerns about unequal tax treatment. Under the previous tax rules, companies had to pay a tax on stock buybacks. However, shareholders who sold their shares during the buyback didn't have to pay taxes on any capital gains. This created an inequity in the tax system, as some shareholders who wished to participate but couldn't were denied this tax advantage.
<h3 id="why-does-sebi-believe-the-buyback-should-be-reopened">Why does SEBI believe the buyback should be reopened?</h3>
1. Buyback Tax Shifted to Shareholders Under New Law

The Finance Bill 2024 shifts the tax burden on buybacks from companies to shareholders. As per the Income Tax Act, 2025, amended by the <a href="https://studycafe.in/finance-act-2026-big-gst-relief-for-indian-companies-providing-intermediary-services-to-foreign-clients-415704.html">Finance Act</a>, 2026, under the revised framework, money received from share buybacks will now be taxed as capital gains in the hands of shareholders.

Previously, companies were required to pay tax on buybacks. But now shareholders will be responsible for paying tax on the gains they earn from selling shares in a buyback.

2. Additional Tax for Promoters

The Finance Act 2026 has also introduced an extra tax component for promoter shareholders. The main objective of this is to prevent tax arbitrage between buybacks and dividend distribution.

3. Regulator Addresses Market Concerns

The capital market regulator has addressed earlier concerns about discontinuing buybacks through the open market under the new tax structure.

"In light of the amendments in the taxation framework introduced by the Income Tax Act, the then concerns for the discontinuation of buy-back of shares or other specified securities from open market through stock exchange, i.e. tax-induced inequity among public shareholders, now stands addressed".

<div class="related-article-inline">Also Read<a href="/centre-appoints-whole-time-member-sebi-for-a-three-year-tenure-period-414756.html" class="related-link">Centre Appoints Whole-Time Member, SEBI for a Three-Year Tenure Period</a></div>

4. Equal Tax Treatment

SEBI recommended conducting such buybacks through a separate buyback window on stock exchanges, as permitted under existing Buyback Regulations.

It further suggested reintroducing the open market buyback method. This would give companies an additional route to undertake <a href="https://studycafe.in/income-tax-department-clarifies-12-surcharge-on-promoters-buyback-gains-414694.html">buybacks</a> while ensuring fair tax treatment for public shareholders.

"It is proposed that the buy-back of shares or other specified securities from open market through stock exchange may be re-introduced as an additional method in terms of Regulation 4(iv) of Buy-Back Regulations. The existing framework as provided in Regulations and Circulars issued thereunder with respect to buy-back from open market through stock exchange would be applicable".

For detailed information, refer to the official PDF

SEBI Proposes Re-introduction of Open Market Buybacks Under Revised Tax Framework

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has issued a consultation paper inviting stakeholders' feedback on its proposal to reintroduce buybacks of shares in the open market.
<h3>Reason for Discontinuation of the Open Market Buyback</h3>
From April 1, 2025, the practice of companies buying back shares from the open market was discontinued. This decision was taken due to concerns about fairness among shareholders and issues related to the tax structure at that time.

[related id="414695"]

Sebi further added that in open market buybacks, it was possible for a company’s entire buyback order to be matched with the sell orders of just one or a few shareholders. As a result, other shareholders who wished to participate might not get the opportunity to sell their shares.

Additionally, there were concerns about unequal tax treatment. Under the previous tax rules, companies had to pay a tax on stock buybacks. However, shareholders who sold their shares during the buyback didn't have to pay taxes on any capital gains. This created an inequity in the tax system, as some shareholders who wished to participate but couldn't were denied this tax advantage.
<h3>Why does SEBI believe the buyback should be reopened?</h3>
1. Buyback Tax Shifted to Shareholders Under New Law

The Finance Bill 2024 shifts the tax burden on buybacks from companies to shareholders. As per the Income Tax Act, 2025, amended by the <a href="https://studycafe.in/finance-act-2026-big-gst-relief-for-indian-companies-providing-intermediary-services-to-foreign-clients-415704.html">Finance Act</a>, 2026, under the revised framework, money received from share buybacks will now be taxed as capital gains in the hands of shareholders.

Previously, companies were required to pay tax on buybacks. But now shareholders will be responsible for paying tax on the gains they earn from selling shares in a buyback.

2. Additional Tax for Promoters

The Finance Act 2026 has also introduced an extra tax component for promoter shareholders. The main objective of this is to prevent tax arbitrage between buybacks and dividend distribution.

3. Regulator Addresses Market Concerns

The capital market regulator has addressed earlier concerns about discontinuing buybacks through the open market under the new tax structure.

"In light of the amendments in the taxation framework introduced by the Income Tax Act, the then concerns for the discontinuation of buy-back of shares or other specified securities from open market through stock exchange, i.e. tax-induced inequity among public shareholders, now stands addressed".

[related id="414756"]

4. Equal Tax Treatment

SEBI recommended conducting such buybacks through a separate buyback window on stock exchanges, as permitted under existing Buyback Regulations.

It further suggested reintroducing the open market buyback method. This would give companies an additional route to undertake <a href="https://studycafe.in/income-tax-department-clarifies-12-surcharge-on-promoters-buyback-gains-414694.html">buybacks</a> while ensuring fair tax treatment for public shareholders.

"It is proposed that the buy-back of shares or other specified securities from open market through stock exchange may be re-introduced as an additional method in terms of Regulation 4(iv) of Buy-Back Regulations. The existing framework as provided in Regulations and Circulars issued thereunder with respect to buy-back from open market through stock exchange would be applicable".

For detailed information, refer to the official PDF

SEBI has proposed reintroducing open market share buybacks under a revised tax framework from May 2026.

SEBI Proposes Re-introduction of Open Market Buybacks Under Revised Tax Framework

Reason for Discontinuation of the Open Market Buyback

Why does SEBI believe the buyback should be reopened?

The Centre has re-appointed Ravi Agrawal as CBDT Chairman on a six-month contract from July 1 to December 31, 2026.

Government Re-Appoints Ravi Agrawal as CBDT Chairman for Six Months

The ITAT Mumbai deleted the Rs 7 lakh addition under Section 69A, holding that credible evidence and consistent explanations outweigh mere suspicion in unexplained cash cases.

ITAT Deletes Rs 7 Lakh Section 69A Addition, Says Suspicion Alone Cannot Replace Proof

The HC dismissed a writ petition challenging personal tax recovery under Section 179, holding that adequate protection had already been granted by directing authorities to first recover dues from the company.

Tax Recovery Must First Target Company: High Court Finds Existing Protection Sufficient and Dismisses Plea

The ITAT sets aside the CIT(A)'s order, holding that under Section 56(2)(x), stamp duty value on the date of allotment applies when part payment was made earlier.

ITAT Rules Stamp Duty Value to Be Considered at Allotment Date under Section 56(2)(x)

The ITAT remanded the case of the Section 80GGC exemption claim, holding that the CIT(A) had dismissed the appeal merely on the grounds of limitation, and the case was not heard on its merits.

ITAT Remands Section 80GGC Donation Case for Fresh Hearing Due to Non-Consideration of Case on Its Merits

From ITR filing to passport fees and banking rules, here are the key financial changes taking effect from July 1, 2026.

Financial Changes From July 1, 2026: What You Need to Know

ITAT remanded the Section 69A cash deposit case to the AO for fresh adjudication after imposing a Rs 15,000 cost on the assessee.

ITAT Grants Fresh Hearing Despite Repeated Non-Compliance, Imposes Rs 15,000 Cost

ITAT held that cash deposits collected from customers for DMT services were merely pass-through funds and not the assessee's taxable income, deleting the Rs 86.98 lakh addition.

ITAT Deletes Rs 86.98 Lakh Addition on Cash Deposits Routed for DMT Transactions

ITAT held that an Assessing Officer cannot estimate profits without first rejecting the assessee's books of account and deleted the entire addition.

ITAT Deletes Estimated Income Addition as AO Failed to Reject Books of Account

Income Tax

Finance

ICAI

Judgement

ITAT

ITAT Delhi

Chartered Accountant

Institute of Chartered Accountants of India

CBDT

The ITAT held that a mere mismatch in a trade creditor's closing balance cannot justify an addition under Section 68 when the purchases, sales, and closing stock have already been accepted by the AO.

Mere Difference in Trade Creditor Closing Balance Cannot Justify Section 68 Addition When Purchases Are Accepted, Rules ITAT

The ITAT has upheld the disallowance of delayed employees' PF/ESI contributions under Section 143(1), ruling that CPC can make such adjustments while processing income tax returns.

Delayed PF/ESI Deposits Can Be Disallowed During ITR Processing, Holds ITAT

The ITAT Delhi remands Section 11 exemption case after the tax authorities fails to prove that educational institute engaged in trade or commercial activities.