ITAT Sets Aside Rs 3.47 Crore Addition, Reopening Beyond 4 Years Without PCIT Approval Is Legally Invalid:

ITAT quashes reassessment for AY 2011-12 due to invalid Section 151 approval and directs deletion of the Rs 3.47 crore addition.
Section 151 Violation Invalidates Reassessment Proceedings

The ITAT Kolkata has quashed the entire reassessment proceedings against Rimjhim Properties Pvt. Ltd. for Assessment Year (AY) 2011-12, holding that the reopening was invalid due to improper approval under Section 151 of the Income Tax Act, 1961.
The case was reopened based on information received from the Investigation Wing regarding a profit of Rs 2.23 lakh and transactions of Rs 19.67 lakh on the National Multi-Commodity Exchange (NMCE). Since the reopening took place more than four years after the end of the relevant assessment year, the required approval had to be obtained from the Principal Commissioner or Commissioner of Income Tax (PCIT). However, the approval was obtained from the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax (ACIT), Range-17, Kolkata. The ITAT held that such approval was invalid, making the Section 148 notice and subsequent reassessment order legally unsustainable.
The Tribunal also noted that the Assessing Officer (AO) did not make any addition concerning the income for which the reassessment was originally initiated. Instead, the AO added Rs 3.47 crore relating to speculation loss from commodity trading. Relying on the decision of the Calcutta High Court in Infinity Infotech Parks Ltd. and other judicial precedents, the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) held that when the income forming the basis of reopening is not assessed, the AO cannot independently assess another income discovered during reassessment proceedings.
It was noted by the tribunal that "said speculation loss was carry forward to the subsequent yeaRs Therefore, the AO has wrongly noted in the assessment order in para 9 that the assessee has wrongly adjusted loss from commodity trading to the loss of Rs3,47,08,982/-. In the appellate proceedings, the ld. CIT(A) confirmed the addition by simply affirming the order of AO. We find that the assessee has not adjusted loss or any income as observed by the Assessing Officer. Therefore, addition confirmed by the ld. CIT(A) resulted in double taxation."
Consequently, the Tribunal directed the AO to delete the addition and partly allowed the assessee’s appeal.
About Author

Saloni Kumari
Content Writer
StudyCafe
Delhi, Delhi, India
3078My Recent Articles
- CBI Arrests Panchkula CGST Superintendent in Rs 25 Lakh Bribery Case for Promising Favourable GST Proceedings
- ITAT Rules CPC Cannot Make Section 143(1) Adjustments Without Giving Taxpayer Prior Opportunity
- ITAT Remands Section 80G Approval Denial for De Novo Consideration After CIT(E) Allows Section 12A Registration under Similar Circumstances
- GST Portal Clarifies OTP Verification for Non-Core Amendment Applications: Option Available Without Login
- CBI Secures Deportation of Red Notice Subject Raghesh Unnikochan from UAE to India in Kerala Murder Case
Loading suggestions…
Recent Posts
All Posts
Recent Posts
All Posts










